"Mum, this tastes like the dishwasher," my daughter said one evening, and pushed her glass back across the table.
I thought she was just being fussy, until I smelled the glass myself and realised she was right. When I held it up to the kitchen window, there was a faint, milky haze on it that I'd always put down to limescale.
Sometimes it is limescale. But often it's what's left of the detergent, and if it's on the glasses, it's on the plates, the cereal bowls and the little plastic cups as well. It's on everything my kids eat and drink from.
A week later a friend sent me a study from the University of Zurich. The researchers had found rinse-aid residue on clean dishes from commercial dishwashers, and in the lab that residue damaged the cells that line the gut. What stuck with me was how simple the reason is: rinse aid goes in during the very last rinse, so nothing comes afterwards to wash it off.
That same night I turned our box of tabs around. It listed phosphonates, plus perfume ingredients that have to be printed on the pack because they can trigger allergies.
I'm not a chemist, and nobody could tell me how much of that actually ends up inside a child. But I knew I didn't want any of it on my kids' plates.
So over the next few weeks I tested five dishwasher detergents on our own family dishes. This is what I'd tell a friend.
My rules
- It has to clean properly. If I'm rewashing plates by hand, I've just swapped detergent on the plate for food on the plate.
- Nothing on the dishes afterwards that I'd worry about my kids swallowing, so no phosphonates, no benzotriazole and no dyes.
- A version with no perfume at all, for bottles and kids' cups.
- A full ingredient list I can find without a degree in chemistry.
Short version: Mother's Earth Dishwasher Sheets are my #1. They clean properly, our glasses came out clear, and you don't need a separate rinse aid. There are no phosphonates, no benzotriazole, no dyes and no bleach in them. The scent-free version has no perfume at all, and it's the one they recommend for baby bottles. Starting at 16p a wash, it's also one of the cheapest products on my list. It's what's in our dishwasher now.
1. Mother's Earth Dishwasher Sheets, by Mother's Earth

My first worry was the obvious one. It's a sheet, thinner than a beer mat. Can something that thin really clean a lasagne dish? Because if it can't, I'm only swapping detergent on the plate for food on the plate.
So on the first load I tried to make it fail. In went Sunday's lasagne dish with the burnt edge, the pan from the scrambled eggs, and the cereal bowls that had been sitting on the table since breakfast.
Everything came out clean, the lasagne dish included.
Then I did the glass test again, with the same glass at the same window. It was clear, and when I ran my finger over it, it squeaked. The layer of chemicals was gone.
That evening my daughter drank her water from it again. This time there was no face, just "Now it tastes like water." I'll take that as five stars from a seven-year-old.
Two German test sites came to the same conclusion: Warentest Online gave the sheets 97 out of 100, and the Prüfengel institute gave them 95. Out of more than 2,100 customer reviews in their shop, 82% are five stars, which is rare for an eco product.
Why nothing is left behind
A normal tab is packed with extras: bleach, phosphonates, perfume, dye, and often a rinse aid on top. Every extra is one more thing that can end up on the plate.
The sheet works differently. Enzymes and soda do the cleaning. The enzymes are like little Pac-Men that eat away food like egg, milk and meat, so there's no need for bleach to get it off. The sheet dissolves completely in warm or cold water, on every programme. Mother's Earth says the sheets leave no residue on the dishes, and our glasses back that up.
What's not in it:
- no phosphonates
- no benzotriazole
- no dyes
- no bleach
- no zinc salts or acrylic polymers
- no separate rinse aid needed
- and in the scent-free version, no perfume at all
The scent-free one is the version I buy, and it's the one they recommend for baby bottles. Our plates smell of nothing now, which is exactly how a clean plate should smell.
Using them is easy: fold one sheet, put it in the detergent drawer and press start. The box is about the size of an envelope, so there's no tub under the sink, and it goes in the paper recycling when it's empty.
Then there's the price, which honestly surprised me. It starts at 16p a wash, which puts it among the cheapest of the five products I tested, and cheaper than Fairy and Finish. Behind it is a small Dutch family business, a mum and her son, and with every order they donate to a cat or dog shelter or a women's refuge that you choose.
That's my #1. If you change one thing in your kitchen this month, I'd make it this one.
2. Ecover All-in-One, by Ecover

Ecover is my #2, and for a while I thought it might win.
It's a Belgian brand that has been making eco cleaning products since 1979, and it says it has never used phosphates or phosphonates in all that time. That's real credit, and it's more than most brands on the supermarket shelf can say.
What kept it off the top spot was the bleach. The All-in-One tablets contain 5 to 15% oxygen bleach, and they list perfume too (limonene, a fragrance ingredient that has to be declared because it can cause allergies). There is a fragrance-free "Zero" version, which is a real plus.
Then there's the price. At around 21p a tablet, Ecover costs about 30% more than Mother's Earth, and over a year of daily washes that difference adds up.
It's a good brand and a big step up from most supermarket tabs, and if you want an Ecover tablet, go for the Zero. I'd just rather have no bleach on the cups my kids drink from, and the All-in-One has it.
3. Frosch Classic, by Frosch

Frosch is the green bottle with the frog that a lot of us grew up with. My mum always had one by the sink. And to be fair, there are no phosphonates on the label.
But every Frosch tab I found was scented, so there was nothing I'd put my kids' cups through without thinking twice. The pack also lists 5 to 15% oxygen bleach. On the Classic tabs, it says right there on the box that you should add salt and rinse aid for an optimal cleaning result. After that Zurich study, rinse aid was the first thing I took out of my cupboard.
On price, Frosch is a little cheaper than my #1, at around 12p a tab. So in the end it comes down to what's inside.
A decent product with a familiar name, but I wanted a plate with nothing on it.
4. Fairy Platinum Plus, by Procter & Gamble

You'll know Fairy from the washing-up liquid by the sink. They're in almost every supermarket, and I'll give them this: the rinse aid is built in, so you don't need an extra bottle.
The label is where it lost me. On the Platinum Plus Lemon tablets I had, the first line is 15 to 30% oxygen bleach. Phosphonates come next, in the 5 to 15% band. And after the word "perfume" comes a list of nine named fragrance ingredients, from citral and citronellol to geraniol and limonene, four of them on the EU list of allergens. Nine, in something that touches every plate in the house.
I couldn't find a version without perfume either, so there was nothing I'd use for the baby bottles.
At around 20p a tablet, you pay about 25% more than for Mother's Earth. It cleans, but for that money I wanted a much shorter label.
5. Finish Ultimate Plus, by Reckitt

Finish is the tab most of us grew up with. It's the best-selling dishwasher brand in the world, it's in every supermarket and every ad break, and yes, it cleans.
It also had the most crowded label of all five. On the Finish Ultimate Plus caps:
- 15 to 30% oxygen bleach
- 5 to 15% phosphonates
- 5 to 15% polycarboxylates
- plus surfactants and perfume ingredients that have to be declared because of allergies, such as limonene and geraniol
I got my calculator out. One cap weighs about 12 grams, and up to 15% of that is phosphonates, so that's up to around 1.8 grams in every single wash, in the same hot water the cereal bowls are sitting in.
For the best drying, the pack also recommends adding Finish rinse aid on top.
All of that costs around 17p a cap, slightly more than Mother's Earth. You pay more, and you get more of exactly what I was trying to keep off our plates.
That's why Finish comes last.
Competitor prices per wash are regular shelf prices in EU supermarkets, checked in October 2026 and converted at £1 = €1.18.
All five side by side
| Price per wash (from) | Version with no perfume | Perfume / declared allergens | Phosphonates (on pack) | Bleach (on pack) | Pack recommends separate rinse aid | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Mother's Earth | 16p | ✓ yes | ✓ none in scent-free | ✓ none | ✓ none | ✓ no, not needed |
| 2. Ecover All-in-One | 21p | yes (Zero) | limonene (not in Zero) | none | 5–15% | no, built in |
| 3. Frosch Classic | 12p | not found | perfume listed | none listed | 5–15% | yes, salt and rinse aid "for an optimal cleaning result" |
| 4. Fairy Platinum Plus | 20p | not found | 9 named, incl. citral, geraniol, limonene | 5–15% | 15–30% | no, built in |
| 5. Finish Ultimate Plus | 17p | not found | limonene, geraniol | 5 to <15% | 15 to <30% | yes, "for optimal drying" |
So, which one?
If you only read one part of this: Mother's Earth, the scent-free one.
It cleans, the glasses come out squeaky clean, and there's nothing in it I'd worry about on my kids' plates. You don't need rinse aid, and starting at 16p a wash it's also one of the cheapest I tested.
And tonight, before you switch your dishwasher on, try the glass test. Hold one up to the window, and you'll know what to do.
#1 Mother's Earth Dishwasher Sheets: Available here
#2 Ecover: Available here
#3 Frosch: Available here
#4 Fairy: Available here
#5 Finish: Available here
Frequently asked questions
Does the sheet go in the detergent drawer or just in with the dishes?
In the detergent drawer. Fold it once, put it in, close the drawer and you're done.
What if my water is very hard?
Add dishwasher salt. Then your glasses stay clear even with hard water, and you still don't need rinse aid.
Does the sheet dissolve on the eco programme too?
Yes, in warm and cold water and on every programme, including eco and quick wash.
Haven't consumer tests named other tabs as the winners?
Consumer tests mostly check how well tabs clean and dry, and cheap tabs can clean well. My question was a different one: what's left on the plate my kids eat from? That's how I ranked them.
2026